The San Francisco Police Department will close its scandal-marred drug lab permanently and use outside testers to analyze narcotics evidence, Police Chief George Gascón said Wednesday.
That will enable the Police Department’s crime lab at Hunters Point to focus on testing of weapons and DNA evidence, areas that are “quite frankly of greater importance to our crime-fighting efforts,” Gascón said.
The department shut down the drug analysis section of the crime lab March 9 amid an investigation into whether now-retired technician Deborah Madden skimmed powdered cocaine and OxyContin evidence.
Prosecutors have dismissed more than 600 cases since the scandal broke. Madden, 60, has not been charged with a crime in connection with the case, but a police investigation is under way.
Police supervision
Gascón said the drug testing done by private labs would be conducted under “our supervision.” The Police Department still would be responsible for ensuring that the lab work meets legal standards.
The drug analysis section was already a headache for the Police Department even before the narcotics-skimming scandal became known. It was down to two civilian police technicians before Madden left in December, and outside auditors found that the section was not properly supervised, evidence was not well secured and problems with its scales were not being documented correctly.
The chief said an outside lab can perform testing for about $100 per sample. By having police officers themselves do some preliminary tests, Gascón believes that the 14,000 tests that the drug analysis section had performed annually an be cut to around 4,000 at outside labs.
Gascón said the preliminary tests that officers have already started doing are accepted by prosecutors to support the filing of charges.
Positive report
Gascón made the announcement at the same time he said a state audit of the DNA testing section of the crime lab found that it was “well-run,” with only some “relatively minor documentation issues.”
He said state auditors are still looking at the crime lab’s weapons section, which test-fires guns and examines ballistics evidence.
In addition to the outside drug testing, Gascón said independent labs will be brought in to cut the department’s backlog of DNA and firearms testing. Recently, a two-year delay in testing DNA evidence in the slaying of a transgender prostitute allowed a suspect to remain unidentified while he allegedly committed four more sexual assaults of transgender prostitutes.
Gascón said the department would not be able to get ahead of its workload without bringing in outside labs. He did not specify where the money to pay for the testing would come from.
Ultimately, Gascón said, the plan is to move the crime lab. Its small Hunters Point location was intended to be temporary, and the land is scheduled to be redeveloped.
Accreditation goal
With all the changes, the chief said he is confident that a national accreditation agency that audited the crime lab late last year will recertify it. Loss of certification could cut off some federal funding for the Police Department and give ammunition to defense attorneys in trials.
The lab is now running on a six-month extension of its five-year accreditation, which ran out in February.
The lab has kept its accreditation even though police officials failed to tell outside auditors about questions surrounding Madden’s behavior for more than two months, even as evidence mounted against her.
Via: sfgate.com